A VC« Spying On Myself (continued) | Main | MP3 of the Week »
Pandora vs. Last.fm
I have had literally dozens of emails from people I know, people who read my blog, friends in the venture business, all recommending Pandora for music disocvery.
Pandora was created by the music genome project and you tell it about some music you like and its starts playing music. Kind of like a personal radio station on your computer. Sounds great right? Well everyone seems to love it but me.
I tried it when it first came out, I even paid for a year in advance (something you don't have to do anymore). I killed it within 10 minutes. It just wasn't coming up with stuff I wanted to listen to.
About every five emails I get suggesting I try Pandora, I give it another try. But it's always the same. I just can't get into it.
Contrast that with Last.fm. I absolutely love Last.fm. I started out using last.fm (in its incarnation as audioscrobbler) to spy on my music listening habits and report them to me and others. You will see some of that data on the left sidebar of my blog in the big red badges. They show what I listened to the most last week and the music I have listened to the most since I started using last.fm.
Then slowly but surely I got sucked into the system. First it was the social networking. I found some friends of mine in the service and connected to them. I check out what they are listening to via last.fm. And I've found people I've never met in last.fm who have similar taste in music to me.
For some reason, I was never compelled to download the last.fm player. I have iTunes, Rhapsody , and emusic and that gives me a fair amount of leeway to sample whatever music I want to check out on my computer. But several weeks ago, I downloaded the last.fm player.
You can listen to personal radio which is based on the music you have listened to. You can listen to neighbor radio which is based on the music your neighbors (people with similar taste to yours) listen to. Or you can listen to "loved tracks" radio which is based on the music you've tagged as "love this track".
I generally listen to neighbor radio and I have been blown away by this service. I get music I really enjoy all the time, but its often music I have never heard or music that I have heard and really love.
Last.fm is great. It requires a number of things from you. First, that you listen to a lot of music on your computer. If you don't there is no way for last.fm to capture your music listening data. Second, that you download the plugin so that they can in fact capture your music listenting data. And third, that you are interested in an online social experience for discovering music.
Pandora is a lot simpler and maybe that's why people like it so much. But for me, last.fm is a lot better. I don't want a computer recommending music to me. I want other people, people who share my taste in music, recommending music to me.
January 23, 2006 My Music , Venture Capital and Technology | Comments (37) | TrackBack (11)
TrackBack
TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/t/trackback/5934/4099749
Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Pandora vs. Last.fm:
» The Incredible Accelerating iTunes boycott from James Governor's MonkChips
Go Fred! And here are some reasons to use last.fmrather than iTunes recommendations.Fair Play Means Fair Use Means No DRMIts not just iTunes should be boycotted, but DRM encumbered music in general. I certainly wouldn't advise boycott... [Read More]
Tracked on Jan 23, 2006 11:59:14 AM
» What's the best music discovery service? from Music Cherry
Which music "discovery" service works best? (Inspired by Fred Wilson's post on roughly the same subject) Music discovery used to be limited to flipping a coin to decide on which of the three albums the record store had in... [Read More]
Tracked on Jan 23, 2006 12:26:44 PM
» http://www.techcrunch.com/2006/01/23/655/ from TechCrunch
Fred Wilson has a good post today comparing the Last.fm and Pandora music services. Hes stronly in favor of Last.fm.
I use and have written about both services. Both services allow you to find new music that you are likely to enjoy. Last.fm does... [Read More]
Tracked on Jan 24, 2006 12:26:16 AM
» Last.fm vs Virgin Radio from frankie roberto blog
James Cridland (of Virgin Radio) compares last.fm (and similar) with Virgin Radio. Whether algorithms can pick music choices better than a radio station Head of Music is an interesting question. Obviously, last.fm and similar have the leg up in that... [Read More]
Tracked on Jan 26, 2006 5:34:51 AM
» Collaborative filtering for music picks up pace from Trends in the Living Networks
I believe that “collaborative filtering” is at the heart of how the networks are coming to life. The basic concept is that we must collaborate to filter the massive information overload we face. We can do this simply by taking... [Read More]
Tracked on Jan 27, 2006 11:59:08 PM
» Pandora and Last.fm: Nature vs. Nurture in Music Recommenders from Steve Krause : Blog
Over the past week, there has been some blog talk (Fred Wilson, TechCrunch, David Porter) comparing music-recommendation services Pandora and Last.fm. I've been using both for the past couple months, making notes along the way with the idea that I'd [Read More]
Tracked on Jan 31, 2006 12:17:59 AM
» Last.fm versus Pandora (Continued) from Mashable*
Steve Krause has contributed to the ongoing Last.fm vs Pandora discussion with an excellent and in-depth post. He writes:
Algorithmically, Pandora versus Last.fm is something like the nature versus nurture debate. Taking the nature side, Pandora... [Read More]
Tracked on Feb 1, 2006 10:34:24 AM
» Short Note about Music Discovery from It looks obvious
Recently I read very interesting comparison between last.fm and Pandora . Both services dealing with music discovery based on past experience. I wasnt aware of last.fm before I read the comparison and based on the warm review that Fred Wilso... [Read More]
Tracked on Feb 3, 2006 2:10:40 PM
» The Music Industry and change. A case study. from Perceptric Forum
How do industries adapt to the new world? Music, for one,is having a rough time. CD sales keep slipping. The music companies keep railing against "piracy", keep defending the indefensible; their own excess. Music was always organized to bring ... [Read More]
Tracked on Feb 3, 2006 8:29:54 PM
» The Dog Test from theQview
I got a call from my brother this afternoon who told me that The music genome is the greatest invention of all time. As i have posted before, I am a big fan of Pandora. But recent posts by Fred [Read More]
Tracked on Feb 10, 2006 2:12:07 AM
» Blogging Snow Job from Tom Watson
With more snow in my front yard than any average Giuseppe in Turin - the meteorologists and my weather-loving father are going nuts - it's the perfect time to settle in, put another pot of coffee on, and noodle around [Read More]
Tracked on Feb 12, 2006 12:07:20 PM
Comments
nice ;)
you should try out the similar artist radio (radio link on artist page) or your personal recommendation radio (pony) in addition to the radio modes you mentioned. this way i found a lot of new (and amazing) artists i never heard of before.
rock'n'roll!
Posted by: mischa | Jan 23, 2006 7:34:57 AM
Ultimately the problem with Pandora is they're trying to algorithmically define music. The problem is music is effective based on a listener's emotional response to it, not their intellectual response to it.
I'm guessing the genome project doesn't have a field in their database for anything as fuzzy as how the music makes you feel.
Posted by: Erik | Jan 23, 2006 7:52:44 AM
Interesting experience, completely the opposite of mine.
I'm w/ the pro-Pandora folks. I think it's great. In fact, it's the first recommendation engine of any sort that has been a positive experience for me, the first one that actually returns music that seems contextually relevant and enjoyable, the first one that doesn't appear to be a crude, kludgey piece of software that does nothing more than track other users (because its recommendations are based on an analysis of the music, not of the behavior of the end users).
It seems like the difference in the two services and in our two experiences is that Pandora is based on music to music comparisons while last.fm is based on user to user comparisons. Personally I've never had much use for social networking software (I'm constantly signing up for these things and never using them even a single day). Nor have I had musch use for Amazon-style recommendation engines that base recommendations on like-buying patterns among end users. But Pandora's approach--based on musical characteristics--is enormously useful to me.
Posted by: Jason Chervokas | Jan 23, 2006 8:50:26 AM
Fred-
Interesting, and completely opposite from my experience.
I love Pandora. In fact, it's the first recommendation engine of any kind that I find useful in the slightest. I think that's because it is based on an analysis of the music, not of the users who like the music.
My experience w/ recommendation engines that look at user patterns has been dismal. I also have little use for social networking software and have never understood all the buzz about it. Every time I sign up for a socialnet it's a one time experience--I sign up and then never return to use the network again. A complete waste. For me last.fm or other music recommendation schemes revolving around trying to determing like patterns among end users are utter busts. But Pandora works fabulously. Perhaps the only time I've found music I didn't know but which I loved via a recommendation engine.
Posted by: Jason Chervokas | Jan 23, 2006 9:13:00 AM
How long do you have to listen to LastFM before its recommendations get good? I'm about 2,000 tracks in (of it monitoring my Itunes) and my analysis so far is "almost but not entirely as bad as Pandora."
Posted by: Mike Orren | Jan 23, 2006 9:42:17 AM
Last.fm looks like a great service. I just can't understand how they STILL don't have a tool to track usage on an iPod.
Posted by: Mr Juggles | Jan 23, 2006 10:08:58 AM
Pandora's greatest strength is it's ability to put in an artist and get a 'sounds like' playlist out of it - this is also it's greatest weakness, the playlist it produces turn into a drone of sameness mostly of artists you've never heard of. Last.FM, on the other hand, because of it's reliance on aggregate playback statistics, gives you a much more interesting playlist, and I much prefer it, even though I get a lot of dropouts in their stream. The tagging features of Last.FM are nice also, however, it can be frustrating since music does not map well into a one-dimensional space – try building a playlist based on the tag ‘Sunday Morning’ – you have no idea if you are getting classical, electronica, soft rock, or what (actually I’d like a mix of all of them). So while I consider Last.FM to be superior, it’s still a long ways from what I’m looking for. There are still to many times when I just give up and turn on the radio.
Posted by: Craig Huizenga | Jan 23, 2006 10:17:44 AM
I have to say that I am in the pro-pandora camp while admitting that I have not spent much time with last.fm. Pandora has been great for me and has been far better than any peer to peer recommendation engine I have used. While I do agree that Pandora does come up with "monotonous" playlists sometimes (due to the fact that it is analyzes music to music and not user to user), I do believe it helps the user to find music and bands that they would have never heard of. Maybe Pandora shouldn't be used as a "radio" and should be used more as a recommendation engine that you listen to and then buy the songs you like (they do have the built in buying feature). That is how I use Pandora. Just my $0.02.
Also, it is worth noting that Pandora has musicians cataloguing the music based on certain characteristics so it is not purely computer run.
On a side note: I did a VentureWeek podcast on the future of music that included Tim Westergren of Pandora along with Ali Partovi of GarageBand.com and Kelley Egan of BestBuy that may be of interest to you and your readers. The permalink is: http://www.ventureweek.com/podcast/2005/11/23/ventureweek-3-music-technology/
Posted by: Eric Olson | Jan 23, 2006 10:57:25 AM
I am a huge fan of last FM for two distinct reasons. Pandora's approach to a computer knowing what i like is against all the principals of how and why i listen to music.
I listen to the music that my friends listen to - or i help them to find new music - thats is a huge part of the enjoyment of music - talking about it and hsaring a life experience associated with it - music cannot be put to me in a vacuum. Pandora's approach has over-reached - kind of like shazam. Its a cool tech so it must work - well Last FM has looked much harder at the user experience side and has found me discovering alot more good music as a result.
As an aside, Last uses some pretty nifty Ajax in talking to your machine - dare i say it fits in a 2.0 category. (oh no)
Posted by: mark slater | Jan 23, 2006 10:58:58 AM
Hi Fred,
You should check out Beatport (www.beatport.com). Not because you would like the music (it's all techno/dance stuff) but because of the interface and business model. It's probably the best UI out there for trying/buying music and anything you buy can be downloaded in 320KBP MP3. A great example of how an under exposed segment of the music industry that isn't dominated by the big labels and their DRM obsession can create a fantastic online buying experience.
Posted by: Bill Burnham | Jan 23, 2006 12:24:53 PM
I agree Fred, I've probably tried Pandora five different times for a couple of hours each in different music genres and have found it's recommendations to be lacking.
Last.fm has worked better for me, and I think I'll start to use it more. My biggest problem with it is that I mostly listen at work at home with Rhapsody, which Last.fm doesn't track. Hopefully, they will soon.
Posted by: Pat McCarthy | Jan 23, 2006 12:58:49 PM
[gasp] Fred, are you on a tear against computer algorithms (Yahoo vs. Google, Knowledge-In vs. Reference Analysis)?? Just kidding. ;-)
I've tried both services during the past two months and have found them useful. One great flaw to Last.fm I've encountered endlessly: when listening to Classical, Last.fm sporadically presents "Classic Rock" in my stream - which is a real turn off (having to fumble for the "PLEASE DON'T PLAY THIS EVER, EVER AGAIN" button between Chopin and Mozart).
Does anyone know what happened to MuBu.com (Music Buddha)?? I purchased at least 100 albums through that service years ago and then it suddenly disappeared. A year later I floated an inquiry to acquire their IP assets, but never heard a peep.
Posted by: Damion Hankejh | Jan 23, 2006 4:22:09 PM
One feature that I like on Pandora is the ability to set up different stations under the same user id. I find myself listening to different kinds of music depending on what kind of mood I'm in. So on Pandora I have set up different stations for my various listening "moods" (classic rock, indie rock, blues, etc.) As far as I know, last.fm does not have this capability, unless you set up different user id's for each category of music that you listen to. If your musical tastes span multiple music genres, your last.fm station will rotate through all of those genres. Someone please correct me if I'm wrong on that. With that said, I'm not 100% sold on the Pandora recommendation engine. Too often I find myself banning songs that miss the mark.
Posted by: Mike D. | Jan 23, 2006 5:27:31 PM
I also prefer last.fm to pandora. I find that I have to continually tinker with pandora to get it to play a mix of music that isn't totally monotonous. Last.fm on the other hand plays a varied mix of music that fits my listening habits and I rarely have to interrupt my work to change it.
Of course the biggest thing with last.fm and pandora is they have to have music in their system that you like. They both have music to fit my tastes fairly well.
Posted by: spi | Jan 23, 2006 5:44:14 PM
I actually use both, starting with the one who's button I find first on windows startup. As soon as I have to change songs too often I switch to the other service.
As some mentioned before, I also noticed Last.fm differing between Music Genres track after track. Since I listen to a wide varity of music, depending on the occasion or my temporary mood, the change in music style, sometimes is annoying.
Both services are still way better than any FM aired radiostation that I can recieve. I live near Munich Germany and all major radiostaions just play crap and those are the I only ones I recieve in acceptable quality.
Posted by: Flo | Jan 24, 2006 2:40:30 AM
"I'm guessing the genome project doesn't have a field in their database for anything as fuzzy as how the music makes you feel."
... or how fuzzy the music makes you feel.
Posted by: Emmet Connolly | Jan 24, 2006 10:00:33 AM
Pandora is reductive- by analyzing what you like, it weeds out what is dissimilar.
Last.fm is expansive- by linking you to other users who listen to similar things, it connects you to music that may not share formal qualities to your current listening habits, but clearly pleases those who share your tastes.
I think Last.fm works a lot better for the obsessive music nerd, because it extends the social experience of finding new bands. I'm someone who is already getting a lot of social input: I dj and write about music and play in a band, so I'm exposed to a lot of music that's just bubbling up. Last.fm completments the programming directors, magazine editors and club bookers who are also front line editors for the impossibly large world of independent music.
I've yet to have Pandora find a hidden gem for me- just some quality second-tier genre bands. Five years ago, nothing in my listening habits would have lead me to electroclash, which I ended up really liking. Two years ago, nothing would have lead me to listen to the neo-folk. I'm much more ambivalent about that, but I am glad I was lead into exploring it.
Posted by: Bendy | Jan 24, 2006 10:05:53 AM
It's crazy how peopl can be so far on either side of this discussion. I'm alos one who gives Pandora a try every few months and absolutely cannot stand it. I haven't tried last.fm yet. Yahoo Launch is OK. This all proves to me that humans make the best DJs. I mostly listen to Sirius online when I'm at my PC.
Posted by: pwb | Jan 24, 2006 2:01:55 PM
I'm a lazy technophobe and I live behind a firewall at the office. I tried installing Last.fm and couldn't make it work - either I'm too stupid or the firewall blocked it. Either way, the Last.fm website is not particularly friendly to new users. They would do well to remember that 99% of their potential users are slugs like me.
Pandora is easy. No doubt it has flaws. I am constantly amazed at what it doesn't recommend (for example, a group formed by over half of the members of the group I used as the seed for a station). I am also amazed at some of the random recommendations it makes - it seems like it tests me to see how far afield it can go before I will reject a song. Still, on the whole, it is useful to me.
I wonder if the level of sophistication of the listener plays a role in determining whether he or she finds pandora useful. By that I mean that I am not a particularly sophisticated musical consumer; much of what pandora has suggested to me is probably music that someone who is really into the music (such as Fred) would have known about.
Posted by: Alan | Jan 25, 2006 7:26:11 PM
I too am a big fan of last.fm
Do you get your album covers you display on your blog from a last.fm plug in there or is last.fm only providing your list of most listened to artists?
Posted by: Anthony | Jan 26, 2006 3:50:54 PM
I'm a huge fan of Last.FM as well, and agree with everything you've said about the relative merits of Pandora. This last week in particular, I've had the "it just never finds anything I want" discussion about Pandora with quite a few people. I suppose if I had more mainstream tastes, Pandora would be more worthwhile, but when I try typing in 5 of my favorite bands to seed it, and it can only find one of them, I quickly lose the desire to keep playing.
Posted by: Chris | Jan 27, 2006 9:26:29 AM
Re: the streaming radio on last.fm
It's even better than that, you can listen to streams based on (your own, or global) tags. I generally listen to my own largish collection of oggs, and I only use the stream to discover new music, through the 'recommended' radio which is one of the greatest features of last.fm IMO. Especially in combination with 'discovery mode' which prevents the same tracks from coming by twice.
Posted by: eric casteleijn | Feb 1, 2006 2:37:27 PM
Last.fm rocks! I've tried Pandora a few times and it just doesn't do it for me. Started using last.fm for the first time today and I've been listening to it for about an hour. The player is easy to use, and far less annoying than Pandora's - also maybe it is just me but I found Pandora quite buggy - the stream would drop out at random and then it would start playing the next song, without "forwarding" to it in the window. Last.fm has yet to drop out - it's every bit as good as listening to a CD. I started out by listing "Elvis" (first thing that came to mind) and already it has played me various tracks, including Mozart and Dean Martin! Don't know how they relate to Elvis but I am *sure* that Pandora would not have given me these tracks...
Posted by: Stephen | Feb 3, 2006 1:41:37 AM
"the problem with Pandora is they're trying to algorithmically define music." Posted by: Erik
Exactly. Music is emotional not technical. Just because two songs use similar sounds, structures, or instrument type, that does not mean both songs are good...certainly doesn't mean I will like both. Those technical aspects are useful, they're just not the most valid predictor of what I want to hear. I mean, when someone plays a song 22 times in a week, they're not thinking, "I can't get enough of this mild rhythmic syncopation and major key tonality," they're just thinking, "Man, I F#!**** LOVE this song!" And that's the predictor I want working for me.
Posted by: Rosco | Feb 4, 2006 7:23:51 PM
My own experience with Pandora is that it gives me more of the same. Which is alright. Sometimes there are some discoveries but not usually.
Generally it's more interesting to have one's horizons broadened. Which happens with the last.fm system.
Exploring other's listening patterns is a wonderful notion. Find some like-minded or admired listeners and enjoy what they listen to and learn. The potential of being a university of music.
Posted by: LVV Dance | Feb 5, 2006 4:08:12 PM
Main RSS Feed of All Posts
VC and Technology Posts Only
